NOTES - 05
EQUIPMENT
MANAGEMENT TIPS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERS
AND
PLANT & MACHINERY ENGINEERS
AN
INTRODUCTION TO CONSTRUCTION PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
HOW
TO PLAN AND SELECT EQUIPMENT FOR A CONSTRUCTION PROJECT
1.0 HOW TO SELECT THE
EQUIPMENT
Factors to be first
considered in selecting suitable equipment are discussed below:
Scope of work to be
carried out: Apart from the evaluation of the quantities of various items of
work and the timeframe within which the work is required to be carried out, the
specification for work will have a bearing on the selection of equipment.
The equipment already
available with the construction agency:
Some items of the
equipment may already be available with the construction agency, presently
idle. Such items, though not ideally suited for the project being evaluated,
may still have to be considered for use. Even though typical outputs with such
equipment may be some-what less, this may have to be counter- balanced against
depreciation for the idle equipment which would otherwise have to be procured.
On many occasions, apparently, idle equipment may prove to be more expensive.
Also time and capital limitations may oblige the construction agency to use the
available equipment. Even if there is no limitation regarding capital, if new
equipments in short supply with long delivery schedules, it is prudent to use
the available equipment.
The money spent on
purchase of construction equipment shall be treated as an investment which the
construction agency is expected to recover with profits during the useful life
of the equipment. The equipment must pay for itself. Thus it is prudent to
think of investing in equipment only when it can be established in advance that
the equipment will earn more than the cost.
2.0 PLANNING FOR
EQUIPMENT
Equipment planning
shall include the following aspects:-
i. Selection of
equipment
ii. Number and sizes
of units
iii. Matching
capacities
iv. Schedule of
procurement
v. Arrangement of
skilled staff for operation and maintenance
vi. Establishment of
service and repair facilities
vii. Maintenance of
spare parts inventory
viii. Decision
regarding number of shifts per operation thus a systematic approach in respect
of planning for equipment is necessary, incorporating all the factors detailed
above. In addition an important factor to be considered is the necessary
inter-disciplinary acceptance of the planning for equipment. In a majority of
the cases project may be headed by a Civil Engineer whereas the construction
equipment management will demand close liaison with mechanical and electrical
engineers. It will be prudent to have detailed consultations among the
disciplines before the final choice of the equipment.
Having taken a
decision to go in for additional equipment, the following factors are required to
be evaluated:
Suitability for job
commissions - The nature of site terrain will often affect the cost of
constructing the plant and its supporting facilities. The plant must be
accessible to transportation facilities to be used. There may be limitations in
respect of the quality and capacity of roads, waterways, bridges etc. which may
limit the size of transport vehicles used.
Infrastructure - The
availability and cost of infrastructure are important considerations:
The supply of
electricity from public utilities is either not available or not dependable.
Diesel powered equipment will be required or electricity may have to be
generated at site. Water supply is equally critical, when required in large
quantities for washing raw materials or for cooling purposes.
3.0 STANDARDISATION OF
EQUIPMENT
It is desirable to
have a minimum number of types of equipment in order to facilitate minimum
inventory of spare parts as well as common maintenance facilities. With minimum
number of types, the task of training skilled manpower for operation and
maintenance for the machines is also streamlined. As far as possible the common
type of prime movers should be envisaged for the different machines. Even for
the routine maintenance the task becomes very complex if such standardization
or at least reduction of varieties is not planned in advance. While it is
comparatively easy to go in for standardization through variety reduction when
all the equipment or project is purchased afresh, the problem gets complicated
if part of the available equipment has to be planned for use along with the
newly purchased equipment. On one of the major projects in India it has been
observed that in the absence of any attempts at standardization, 19 different
types of lubricants, oils and greases have to be maintained at the project
site. With such large variety of oils, mistakes in identifications and wrong
issues resulting in deterioration of machines are quite common.
4.0 SIZES OF THE
EQUIPMENT
Items of equipment are
available in a wide variety of sizes - small, medium and large. While large
size equipment is capable of better outputs, the repairs and maintenance
facilities need to be greater as transportation to and from the project site is
usually difficult and expensive. However, large-size machines are known to be
more sturdy and suitable for though working conditions. In the event of failure
of one primary unit of large-size, several other large-size units of matching
operations may be rendered idle. The need for having standby equipment is also
required to be considered before choosing the size of the equipment. On many
occasions the choice of two medium-size items vis-a-vis one large-size may
prove beneficial.
It is desirable to
select from established manufacturers of proven capacities. The ready
availability of spare parts with the manufacturers shall also be ensured before
choice of the equipment. It is generally easier to dispose of standard
equipment supplied by well known manufacturers.
The machine selected
should be as far as possible capable of multiple functions, operating with
inter-changeable tools. Most of the earthmoving equipment items from
established manufacturers provide this facility.
For specialized work
such as tunneling etc. the choice of the equipment needs very careful
consideration as they are capital intensive. The equipment may be idle for long
periods between uses unless the construction agency has already secured a large
number of identical projects where the equipment can be used over its useful
life without interruption. Otherwise it is often desirable to go in for
reconditioned secondhand equipment.
5.0 CHOICE OF
PRIME MOVERS
The choice of prime
movers depends on the following factors :
i. Fuel efficiency
ii. The engine speed
iii. The transmission
systems
Slow speed engines
have an advantage for a number of machines in the Indian context. The wear and
tear is minimum. Maintenance requirements are not complex. Parts replacement is
also comparatively flexible. The life of the machine is also long.
However, from fuel
efficiency consideration, high speed machines are advantageous.
6.0 PLANNING
FOR REPLACEMENT
Even where the
available equipment is used, it is necessary to plan for replacement of such
equipment at the end of its useful life. The cost of maintenance and repairs
generally increase in geometric progression with older equipment. The total
cost of owning and operating such old equipment will have to be evaluated
before a decision is taken on replacement.
Apart from cost
considerations, replacement may also be required due to obsolescence of the
equipment, non availability of spare parts, environmental protection
considerations etc. At the time of replacement the choice of new equipment
should take into account the requirements of standardization and variety
reduction.
7.0 CLIMATIC
CONDITIONS
The climatic
conditions under which the equipment will be required to operate will need
consideration at the time of selection of equipment. Many of the items of
equipment are originally designed for use in temperate climates. Suitable
modifications are required for using such equipment in hot climatic conditions,
in addition to revised maintenance schedules, frequency of lubrication and oil
change etc.
8.0 LAYOUT OF
CONSTRUCTION PLANT
The layout should
ensure minimum movement of material, equipment and personnel as well as minimum
processing time. Proper drainage should be planned. The wind conditions should
be evaluated and provided for. Operations of items like tower cranes are highly
prone to heavy winds. Crushers should be oriented so that the dust is carried
by the wind away from the crusher. Supporting facilities such as generators,
offices, stores etc. should be located out of the path of the dust flow.
Adequate space must be provided for handling and storing raw materials as well
as finished products. Covered storage may be required to protect it from the
weather. Depending on the size of the project, paved areas may have to be
provided for storing raw materials such as aggregates.
Wherever possible,
separate service roads should be provided for incoming materials and outgoing
products. As most of the service roads are not paved, provision must be made
for adequate regular maintenance.
SELECTION OF EQUIPMENT
- GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS
The proper selection
of equipment for any construction project involves decision on a number of
parameters for economic operation and maintenance of the equipment. The
following aspects need detailed consideration at the selection stage:-
1. Suitability for the
job
The equipment selected
should obviously match the dimensions of the job and ground conditions.
Climatic and other operating conditions are also required to be borne in mind.
A piece of equipment designed and manufactured for operations in temperate
climatic conditions will not necessarily function satisfactorily under hot
climatic conditions.
2. Use of available
equipment
Use of available
equipment, though not operating under optimum conditions, may sometimes have to
be resorted to, taking into account the limited utility of any new equipment,
depreciated low value of the available equipment etc. In short, the economics
of the two alternatives will have to be evaluated before the final choice.
4.
Size of the equipment
The choice is
indicated as neither a minimum number of large-size machines nor several units
of medium/small capacity machines. Large size units will require matching
equipment of equally larger sizes. It also suffers the disadvantage of total
breakdown of operations in the event of one large-size unit's failure to
operate. On the other hand, the main advantage is that the larger units are
generally sturdier and are suitable for tough working conditions. The size of
the standby equipment will also be a consideration in the choice of the size of
the equipment.
4. Variety Reduction
It is desirable to
have the minimum possible number of varieties of equipment. Preferably, the
prime movers should be of a common type to facilitate interchange of prime
movers between various machines, if required. Variety reduction also results in
more efficient maintenance program.
5. Standardization
Standardized equipment
manufactured in large number is generally readily available and cost effective.
Spare parts availability is also an advantage. The resale value of the standardized
equipment is always higher.
6. Versatility
The selected unit
should, if possible, be capable of performing more than one function. In short,
it should be of multi-purpose variety for use on different types of projects.
7. Utilization
The size and numbers
of the equipment shall be fixed to ensure full utilization of the equipment on
the projects. The economics of ownership and operation of the equipment shall
be of paramount consideration.
8. Selection of
manufacturer
It is desirable to
have the units supplied by reputed manufacturers and to have minimum number of
different sizes/makes of equipment.
9. Suitability for
local conditions
The equipment should
be such that the necessary technical and operating personnel could be easily
obtained or trained with minimum efforts.
10. Adaptability
Adaptability for
future use if machine is likely to work only for a short time on a particular
project, and subsequent utilization on other projects should be kept in view.
Full utilization of the equipment should be aimed at during the life of the
machine, so that investment could be recovered with profits during its useful
life.
11. Technical
Considerations
The efficient
performance of any piece of equipment and its service life are conditioned by
the following factors -
1. Strength
2. Rigidity
3. Vibration stability
4. Resistance to wear
5. Heat resistance
6. Reliability
7. Maintainability
Strength: is defined
as the property of a part to resist failure when acted upon by external loads.
Parts of the machine may be acted upon by normal, accidental or emergency
loads. The magnitude and nature of normal loads correspond to those specified
for a given machine. These loads are used in calculating the durability of the
machines. Accidental loads result from the most unfavorable combinations of
loads acting upon a part of the machine. Such loads induce maximum stresses and
as such, strength calculations are based on these loads. Emergency loads may be
imposed as a result of faulty performance of machine or when the operating instructions
are violated. These loads are introduced for calculating and planning safety
devices so that the load acting on any part shall not exceed the accidental
load referred to above.
While deciding on the
basic strength requirements, a safety factor is used to account for the
following aspects:
a. Variation in
uniformity of the physical and mechanical properties of the material.
b. Variation in the
possible determination of design loads and stresses.
c. Factor to allow for
specific safety requirements based on the criticality of the component and the
degree of consequent damage. Where safety of human lives is involved, the
safety factor is calculated based on the national and international norms.
Rigidity
The rigidity of a part
is characterized by the elastic deformation caused by the loads acting upon it.
To maintain the requirements of rigidity the size and the quality of material
are so chosen as to limit the magnitude of the deformation to the permissible
level.
Otherwise normal
performance of the machine may be disturbed - for instance, if the shaft for a
gear system is of insufficient rigidity the performance of this system is
disturbed as the shaft undergoes bending.
Vibration stability
Is defined as the
capacity of each component to withstand vibration while the machine is in
operation. Extensive vibration also results in damage of parts due to fatigue
stresses.
Wear Resistance
The wear of a part
manifests itself in changes in dimensions and properties of its surfaces. The
following types of wear are indicated:
a. Mechanical -
abrasive wear accompanied by brittle surface failure.
b.
Molecular/mechanical wears resulting in seizing of the surface of two meeting
parts.
c.
Corrosion-mechanical wear
d. Molecular/thermal
wear due to friction between parts Any type of wear reduces the strength,
rigidity, durability and reliability of a part. It may also result in greater
dynamic loads due to varying clearances in parts. Wear is reduced by proper
lubrication, decreasing the pressure between them and also by preventing
exposure of the affected surfaces to corrosive influences and abrasive
particles.
Reliability is defined
as the property which facilitates the functions during the service life of the
machine, maintaining its operating characteristics within the intended limits.
Reliability may be determined either for a machine as a whole or for its
individual component, units and parts. Reliability is estimated by means of
various indices such as a number of failures, average service life in hours,
total distance logged in kilometers etc.
Maintainability of a
machine is expressed as a ratio of the time the machine is rendered idle for
repairs and maintenance to the operating time. Factors such as ready
availability of parts for replacement and the percentage of parts that are
interchangeable are also relevant.
Classification of
Equipment
Any typical
construction equipment may be classified in a number of ways:
a. The type of job
b. The nature of the
working process
c. The operating
conditions
d. The prime mover
e. The type of
transmission
f. The output capacity
g. The type of control
gear
In terms of the type
of job, equipment used for construction operations are generally divided into
the following classes :
i. Horizontal
off-track vehicle
ii. Load lifting machines
for erection work
iii. Machines for
loading/unloading operations
iv. Continuous
conveyance machines
v. Material handling
machines
vi. Machines for
excavation and preparatory works
vii. Drilling and pile
driving equipment
viii. Machines for
working on stone materials
ix. Materials for
preparation, transportation and placement of concrete and mortar
x. Machines for
finishing work
xi. Machines for
making reinforced concrete products
xii. Power tools
xiii. Supporting
equipment
In terms of duty, the
equipment belonging to various groups are classified as intermittent action or
continuous action machines.
The following types of
prime movers are used as sources of power for operating the equipment.
a. Electric motor
b. Internal combustion
engine
c. Pneumatic motor
d. Hydraulic motor
e. A combination of
two or more sources for example : diesel-electric driven
Mobility
Machines are
classified as stationary and mobile. The mobile units can further be subdivided
as self-propelled, semi-trailer and trailer types. Based on the running gear,
machines may be classified as crawler, pneumatic type units, rail mounted units
and walking units.
E
ESTIMATION
THE EQUIPMENT PERFORMANCE NORMS
Selection of Equipment
needs careful thought to ensure efficient and effective performance. Though the
actual selection would depend on factors like type of the work, its magnitude
location etc. certain guidelines can be laid down. Basically the various
operations involved are as below:
a. Earth moving
i. Clearing and
grubbing
ii. Stripping
iii. Earth work in
cutting and embankment
iv. Spreading earth
for bank work
v. Providing camber
vi. Watering
The following Table
shows the suitable equipment for the works mentioned above.
EARTH
MOVING OPERATION
Table-1
Selection
of Equipment
No.
|
Operation
|
Suitable Plant
|
Remarks
|
||
i.
|
a.
|
Clearing & Grubbing
|
a.
|
Tractor mounted dozer
|
Blade to be used in bulldozing position
|
Light/scrub & grass
|
b.
|
Grader motor
|
For light scrub
|
||
Clearing debris rubble
|
a.
|
Tractor mounted dozer
|
|||
b.
|
Tractor with heavy duty winch
|
For large objects
|
|||
ii.
|
Stripping Top soil
|
a.
|
Dozer, tractor mounted
|
||
b.
|
Motorised- Scraper
|
300 m. to 3000 m. haul
|
|||
Tractor towed Scraper
|
60 m. to 3000 m. haul
|
||||
Grader, motor
|
light stripping
|
||||
c.
|
|||||
iii.
|
Earthwork in cutting and embankment
|
a.
|
Dozer, tractor mounted
|
||
Light & medium soils
|
b.
|
tractor towed scraper
|
for hauls 60 m. to 300 m.
|
||
a.
|
c.
|
motorised scrapers
|
hauls 300 m. to 3000 m.
|
||
d.
|
Grader motor
|
||||
e.
|
Excavator and dump trucks
|
||||
f.
|
Front end loader
|
||||
g.
|
Tipping bucket
|
||||
b.
|
Heavy soil
|
a.
|
Dozer Tractor mounted
|
Upto 90 m. haul
|
|
b.
|
Scraper ractor towed with pusher tractor to help loading or
preceded by tractor towed rooter or tractor mounted ripper
|
||||
Motorised scraper with pusher tractor or preceded by tractor
towed rooter
|
haul 60 m. to 300 m.
|
||||
Grader motor preceded by tractor towed rooter.
|
|||||
c.
|
|||||
haul 300 m. to 3000 m.
|
|||||
d.
|
|||||
iv.
|
Spreading earth for bank work
|
a.
|
Scraper tractor towed
|
60 m. to 300 m.
|
|
b. c.
|
Scraper motorised
|
300 m. to
|
|||
d.
|
Grader motor
|
3000 m.
|
|||
e.
|
Tipping trucks
|
||||
Dozer, tractor mounted
|
|||||
v.
|
Providing camber
|
a.
|
Grader motor
|
||
b.
|
Dozer, tractor mounted
|
||||
c.
|
Scraper tractor towed motorised
|
||||
vi.
|
Watering (Embankment or surfacing)
|
Truck or trailer mounted water tanker with water pump and
sprinkler
|
Table
– 2
No.
|
Work
|
Plant
|
Remarks
|
|
i.
|
Compaction of bankwork and subgrade soils
|
a.
|
Sheepsfoot roller
|
|
b.
|
Smooth wheel and roller
|
|||
c.
|
Pneumatic tyred roller
|
|||
d.
|
Vibratory roller
|
|||
e.
|
Power rammer
|
|||
ii.
|
Granular base and sub base
|
a.
|
Smooth wheeled roller
|
|
b.
|
Vibratory roller
|
|||
iii.
|
Macadam base/ sub base
|
a.
|
Smooth wheeled roller
|
|
iv.
|
Mix-in-situ bituminous base
|
a.
|
Steel wheeled roller
|
|
Vibratory compactor
|
||||
v.
|
Plant mix base course or surface course
|
a.
|
Three wheel roller
|
|
b.
|
Tandem roller
|
Table
- 3
Plant
and Equipment Concrete
No.
|
Operation
|
Pavement
Plant
|
i.
|
Manufacturing
Concrete
|
Concrete
mixers
|
ii.
|
Compaction
|
Surface
vibrators
|
iii.
|
Transporting
Concrete
|
Equipment
for conveying concrete will depend on site conditions
|
iv.
|
Curing
of concrete
|
Water
tanker truck mounted
|
Table
- 4
Plant
for bituminous road pavement
No.
|
Operation
|
Plant
|
|
i.
|
Surface dressing
|
i.
|
Bitumen boiler with
sprayer or bitumen pressure sprayer
|
ii.
|
Chip spreader
|
||
iii.
|
Smooth wheeled roller
|
||
ii.
|
Penetration grouting semi grout/full grout
|
i.
|
Bitumen boiler with
sprayer or Bitumen pressure sprayer
|
iii.
|
Premix carpet
|
i.
|
Hotmix plant of capacity,
6-10 T per hour
|
iv.
|
Seal coat
|
i.
|
Paver finisher
|
ii.
|
Tipping truck
|
For
work of large magnitude two or more mini hot-mix plants, a paver finisher and
tipping truck for haulage form a desirable combination.
.....
Table contd.
v.
|
Hot mixed bitumious macadam or Asphaltic concrete
work
|
i.
|
Bitumen
boiler with sprayer
|
General
Notes:
1. Comparisons between
crawler mounted and wheel mounted bulldozers.
Crawler
mounted
|
Wheel
mounted
|
||
i.
|
Delivers
greater tractive effort.
|
i.
|
Higher
travel speed
|
ii.
|
Suitable
for operations in loose or muddy
soil
|
ii.
|
More
output
|
iii.
|
Can
operate in rocky formations without damage
|
iii.
|
Causes less fatigue to operators
|
iv.
|
Lower
pressure under tracks hence greater flotation
|
iv.
|
Travels on paved surface without causing damage
|
v.
|
More
versatile
|
No
hauling equipment necessary
|
2.
Comparison between oil fired and coal fired/firewood fire
Boilers
Oil
Fired
|
Coal
fired/Firewood fired
|
||
i.
|
Less
heating time
|
i.
|
Less
initial cost
|
ii.
|
More
thermal efficiency
|
ii.
|
unskilled operator can operate
|
iii.
|
Better
output
|
iii.
|
Operation cost is less
|
iv.
|
Needs
less number of tar/bitumen boilers
|
iv.
|
Less
efficient as compared to oil fired
|
v.
|
Easy
to start/shut
|
||
vi.
|
No
consumption of fuel when standing idle
|
||
vii.
|
Suitable
for any season
|
||
viii.
|
Requires
trained operators
|
||
ix.
|
High
initial cost
|
5. Comparison between batch
type Hot-mix-plant and continuous hot mix plant
No.
|
Continuous
type
|
Batch
type
|
|
i.
|
Supply
is continuous and hence output is more
|
i.
|
Better
control on mix
|
ii.
|
Related
equipment can also be put to maximum use
|
ii.
|
Gives
better surface
|
iii.
|
Quality
of mix can not be controlled precisely
|
iii.
|
Less
output
|
iv.
|
High
initial cost
|
Classification of Hot
mix plants
These are classified
on the basis of capacity and their mobility.
1. 3T to 10T per hour
capacity mobile or mini-plant
These plants are
mounted on pneumatic wheels and can be moved easily. They are suitable for
handling small lengths say up-to 10 km. But due to frequent shifting the total
output is less. Because of the small capacity paver finisher cannot be used
with a single plant but is ideally suited for manual work. Mini-plant of this
nature is good for small jobs particularly in the nature of repairing and
maintenance.
But mini plants have
certain limitations.
i. The feed to the
plant is taken from the road side and as such there is no precise control on
the quality of output.
ii. Temperature loss
is more.
iii. As paver finisher
cannot be used with mini-plant and work is done manually the quality of the
road surface may not be up-to the mark.
iv. Collection of the
aggregate is required all along the road and this may affect gradation of the
feed at different locations and as such there may not be uniformity over the
entire length of the road.
v. Frequent shifting of
the plant is involved in the use of mini-plant.
2. 10T to 45T per hour
capacity or Portable plant.
Plant of this type can
be easily dismantled and transported by road or rail. With its capacity it can
handle road length upto 40 km. i.e. if such a plant is kept at a place it can
operate for 20 km. on either side.
3. Up-to 60T per hour
static plant.
These plants are
installed at a permanent location for a long time. They can supply hot mix
up-to a lead of about 30 km. In other words a road length of 60 km. can be
easily tackled by a static plant installed at a suitable location midway.
Outputs and
performance of the equipment:
Manufacturers of the
equipment give output of their products. This however is based on ideal
conditions which are difficult to obtain on working site. Naturally the actual
output of equipment is different and may vary from site to site.
One of the important
tasks of the planner is to assess the requirement of the plant and equipment on
a particular job. For this he must know:
i. total quantity of
work to be done and
ii. the output of the
equipment proposed to be used.
Factors affecting the
performance of equipment:
Factors which affect
the performance and hence the output of an equipment have to be carefully
considered.
Factors related to the
job are required to be considered which include:
i. Swell and shrinkage
of material handled
ii. Gradient of the
haul road
iii. Rolling
resistance of the haul road
iv. Climate and
topography
v. Tractice efficiency
vi. Moisture content
of materials handled
vii. Altitude
In addition to the
above factors which more or less have to be accepted as they are on a job there
are factors which relate to the way the job is managed. These factors include:
i. how well the
operators are trained
ii. layout on job site
iii. proper matching
of various allied equipment
iv. availability of
the facilities for maintenance, repairs etc.
v. management and
worker relationship
The actual output of
equipment is a combined effect of factors related to job and to the management.
While assessing annual output number of working days (actually the number of
working hours) has relevance. Working days depend on the climatic conditions
i.e. temperature, rainy season etc. Both these factors influence bituminous
work. Assuming normal condition and single shift about 200 working days or
about 1500 working hours would be reasonable basis of calculation.
Even though
manufacturer indicated details regarding output, fuel/energy consumption, it is
always desirable to maintain regular and elaborate records of the time for
which the equipment is used, fuel/energy consumed, expenses on repairs and
maintenance and output so that useful data in respect of cost per unit output
or cost per unit time of use of the equipment etc. can be generated.
Estimating the
requirement of the equipment:
Equipment on a road
work (or on any work) has either to be purchased, obtained on hire or
transferred from some other project. In either of the cases a fairly accurate
estimate of the requirement of equipment has to be done so as to ensure that
expenditure on equipment is not wasted. This needs planning well in advance.
Factors to be
considered are:
i. What is the most
desirable sequence of operations involved in the work?
ii. Which of the
operations are to be performed by the machinery?
iii. In case some or
all equipment is to be transferred from other projects how the programs of both
the projects to be arranged so that there is no undue to and from movement of
the equipment and at the same time the work is completed in optimum time.
Data required:
Basic data required
for estimating the equipment are:
i. Quantities of items
of work : Road Project is sub divided in operations like (a) Earth work (b)
Aggregate production (c)transporting aggregate to road (d) metalling (e)
compaction (f) wearing surface -- concrete/bituminous surface etc. Quantities
of items are worked out.
ii. Period of
completion of the project.
Period of completion
would depend on the duration required for the various constituent items and the
sequence in which they are proposed to be executed. Normally a given road work
has to be completed in a stipulated period particularly when the work is to be
completed on contract. In such cases the duration of the constituent operations
have to be adjusted taking into consideration the activity interrelation and
overall period of completion. While fixing the activity durations due allowance
must be made for bad weather, monsoon, loss of time due to shifting equipment,
break down, repairs and maintenance of equipment etc.
iii. Normally no work
is possible for 3 to 4 months in a year due to monsoon. Further considering
weekly holidays normally 25 days could be considered to be available for
working. Though a working day is considered to comprise 8 hours, a part is spent
in inevitable operations like shifting, waiting etc. Thus in about 200 days
available, working hours would be about 1200-1500.
iv. From (i) to (iii)
above a fair estimate of requirement of equipment can be done. Over and above
this a suitable provision (to the extent of 10%) is done as stand by to take
care of break down or unforeseen circumstances.
Conclusion
It would be obvious
from the above details that the planner/estimator should have a good
understanding of the work site, methods/techniques of work as well as the
characteristics of the equipment, their output, factors affecting the output
etc.
Appendix 1 shows the
probable life of equipment and machines used on road construction while
Appendix 2 shows their output per working day.
Appendix - 1
Approximate working life of the
road construction equipment.
No.
|
Equipment
|
Working
life (hrs)
|
1.
|
Stone
crusher(400 mm x 225 mm size) capacity 10-12T per hour
|
10,000
|
2.
|
Granulator
(300 mm x 175 mm) 4-5T per hour
|
10,000
|
3.
|
Diamond
drilling machine
|
12,000
|
4.
|
Tractor
Dozer
|
12,000
|
5.
|
Motor
grader (3.6 m & above)
|
15,000
|
6.
|
Motorised
scraper
|
12,000
|
7.
|
Towed
scraper
|
15,000
|
8.
|
Pusher
(crawler tractor)
|
12,000
|
9.
|
Soil
stabiliser
|
12,000
|
10.
|
Trucks
5T & below
|
1,50,000
|
11.
|
Trucks
above 5T
|
2,00,000
|
12.
|
Rear
dumper
|
10,000
|
13.
|
Bitumen
boiler
|
10,000
|
14.
|
Bitumen
mixer
|
10,000
|
15.
|
Bitumen
pressure distributor
|
15,000
|
16.
|
Bituminous
Hot mix plant
|
15,000
|
17.
|
Paver
finisher
|
15,000
|
18.
|
Chip
spreader
|
15,000
|
19.
|
Road
Roller 8-10T
|
18,000
|
20.
|
Tandem
Roller 4-6T
|
18,000
|
21.
|
Concrete
mixer 7-10T
|
8,000
|
22.
|
Vibrator
|
8,000
|
23.
|
Air
Compressor
|
10,000
|
24.
|
Diesel
pumping set
|
10,000
to 12,000
|
25.
|
Truck
mounted water tanker
|
1,00,000
|
Appendix - 2
Probable
output of road construction equipment
under
normal conditions of working
No.
|
Equipment
|
Average
output per day
|
Remarks
|
1.
|
Scraper
motorised 9 - 11 cum size
|
138
- 140 cum
|
|
2.
|
Scraper
towed 7 - 8.5 cum size
|
120
cum
|
|
3.
|
Rollers
|
||
a.
on soil
|
425
cum
|
||
b.
murrum and gravel
|
320
cum
|
||
c.
Rubble soling
|
42
cum
|
||
d.
Wearing surface of metal
|
30
cum
|
||
e.
Surface coating 1st coat
|
650
SQM
|
||
f.
Surface coating 2nd coat
|
930
SQM
|
||
g.
20 mm carpet
|
465
SQM
|
||
h.
Seal coat
|
930
SQM
|
||
i.
Bitumen macadam
|
280
SQM
|
||
4.
|
Sheeps
foot roller Earth work
|
595
- 600 cum
|
|
5.
|
Soil
stabilizer
|
115
SQM
|
|
6.
|
Hot
mix Plant (20T - 30T capacity)
|
120
T
|
|
7.
|
Paver
Finisher (75T - 100T per hour)
|
450
T
|
|
8.
|
Bitumen
Boiler
|
2250
kg
|
|
9.
|
Stone
Crusher (400 mm x 225 mm)
|
72
cum
|
|
10.
|
Granulator
|
24
cum
|
|
11.
|
Trucks
for transporting materials on well maintained road one way lead 8 km
|
6
trips
|
|
one
way lead 16 km
|
5
trips
|
||
one
way lead 32 km
|
4
trips
|
||
12.
|
Water
tanker
|
||
one
way lead 4 km
|
14
trips
|
No comments:
Post a Comment